Recent concerns about a political donation by a Mullvad co-founder have raised questions about the Tor Project's funding relationship with the company. We are not terminating the relationship but are setting clear boundaries on our relationship with Mullvad.
Members of the Tor community have asked us to explain how continued collaboration with Mullvad fits with the Tor Project's human rights mission. We have heard both calls to end the relationship and concerns about what that would mean for Tor's work and the communities affected. We want to explain our decision to continue our technical collaboration with Mullvad and acknowledge the difficult trade-offs behind it. Our decision followed a thorough due diligence process that involved extensive discussions with community members, staff, and the board, a staff survey, and detailed financial analysis and scenario planning.
The Tor Project’s mission is to advance human rights and freedoms. We build privacy and anti-censorship tools that people use to protect themselves from repression and surveillance, and express themselves freely. We will continue this work alongside communities whose rights are under threat.
While Tor defends free speech, not all speech is equally compatible with our mission. We strongly oppose rhetoric that threatens other human rights and freedoms.
The work to promote and preserve the human right to privacy, free speech, and free access to information online is severely under-resourced. This work requires and benefits from collaboration across organizations. Sometimes that work requires making difficult compromises to advance specific goals we know will benefit our communities in the long run.
We are continuing our technical collaboration with Mullvad to sustain work that Tor users and contributors depend on. This collaboration has helped improve the structure, maintainability, and auditability of Tor Browser’s codebase, expanded feedback from users beyond Tor Browser’s core audience, and created a lower-risk environment to test features that may later benefit Tor Browser users. It also gives more people access to online privacy through an additional free, open-source tool that serves different user needs. We recognize that the potential benefits to Mullvad of such a collaboration are difficult for some in our community to accept. Our responsibility is to ensure that this collaboration does not compromise our mission or the Tor Project's independence.
Tor Project has paused proactive co-branding with Mullvad. That pause applies to joint promotional activity while the technical collaboration continues in alignment with our narrowly scoped agreement. We have also reviewed how Mullvad Browser is described and endorsed on our owned channels, and clarified language suggesting broader alignment between our values. These changes are intended to describe the relationship more accurately and avoid notions of implied endorsement.
We know this decision will not satisfy everyone. Continuing the collaboration carries a cost to trust for some in our community, and we take that seriously. We are grateful to the members of our community who have raised concerns, asked hard questions, and reminded us what is at stake. Those concerns are shaping our path forward. Tor’s mission has always required both principle and pragmatism. We will continue to defend privacy, anonymity, freedom of expression, and access to information while making clear that our collaborations must serve, and never obscure, our human rights commitments.
It is sad to see that Tor Project went in this direction, and it is the reason I have had to resign as a Tor Browser developer
I would have hoped the public statement had been more honest about the relationship with Mullvad, because “technical collaboration” is a bit misleading. Tor Project entirely makes and builds Mullvad Browser for Mullvad, since there are no Mullvad developers who work on the browser. And Mullvad does not provide any technical input for Tor Browser. Instead, Mullvad provides money as the exchange.
Good. Mullvad is a uncompromising leader in the defense of freedom of speech and information. Its mission closely aligns with Tor Project. Please do not stray from that mission by giving in to the loud voices outraged at the latest thing.
That statement reads like something a cartoony evil corporation would write to placate the masses while they poison the water supplies or do some other nefarious deed behind the scenes.
The money from the guy at Mullvad is what percent of the budget? Is all money from donors scrutinized?
I donate (small amount) to Tor. What if my view is the same as that guy from Mullvad? You would not know and take my money. It’s not but I could be faking it to look good to some.
Does your bank take deposits from bad guys or invest in things you disagree with? What about the owners of your supermarket or café. Do they support stuff you are against? Bottom line: none of us really fully know what is going on. If that guy had been a nobody or unknown or written an anonymous cheque this would not be an issue.
Now what if all the money would dry up and Tor went belly up. There would be no need to quit.
Anyway the AI tech bros say we will all be dead in 10 years.
If you read this, then Mullvad’s post, then Daniel (the human)'s post, it all becomes clear… Money seems to make some forget that not everyone has their privileges.
I don’t know where this notion of “if you don’t like those rules, you can easily move to another place” comes from, how many people outside of his immediate circle he has spoken to in order to come to this conclusion.
I am an immigrant, it was not easy to go through all of it even with the benefit of dual citizenship.
I found that opinion to be dismissive (to say the least). To say such things when you might not really know how difficult it is to move away?
But, also, I find disheartening that others would have such an easy time just shrugging the whole thing away.
Tolerance of the intolerant, is that what this is about? It never ends well.
Freedom that tramples over others isn’t freedom at all, just bidding time until one becomes the next “other” that such political affiliations present as the scape goat to their applauding crowds.
I, for one, condemn this. You, dear reader, will do what you will.
While Tor defends free speech, not all speech is equally compatible with our mission.
Obviously not and the Tor Project very wisely does not open the can of worms that is the kinds of ‘speech’ that flows over the tor network.
Privacy web browsers are technologies which increase the ability of users to remain anonymous, and at the same time keep their own views on any particular subject free from monitoring and potential censorship/interference. I believe the Left/Right libertarian political dichotomy needs to be seen as a largely artificial one, if one considers this goal as paramount. That said, I respect the position of folks like @henry1 who feel they need to take a moral stand.
The potential loss of Mullvad browser would harm users. This is the right decision.
I had to go back and read all the detail about this Daniel Berntsson guy. He says it’s a private donation made with his own money just like me and Tor. Was that money dirty as in proceeds of drugs, arms dealing, human trafficking, etc? I think not. If it were then it’s another story.
As the son of an immigrant I think his “remigration” ideas are of full of (S-word I cannot write here). That is my personal opinion which I am allowed to have just like he is allowed to have his full of S-word opinion.
But I can agree with him that providing a method of circumventing censorship is important. There are 8 billion of us and if we had to agree with everyone about everything nothing would get done.
The solution to this “remigration problem” is to arrange things such that these people do not need to move. (ie: are in a good safe place where they are). That’s another story though.
This sounds weird. It implies we should not be tolerant of the intolerant… which make us the intolerant also… so we should then be intolerant of ourselves. Hmmmm.
… and created a lower-risk environment to test features that may later benefit Tor Browser users
… You’re not using Mullvad Browser users as guinea pigs, right? XD
Tolerance of the intolerant
I usually consider “tolerance” as a kind of multi-party peace treaty, it’s supposed to make people less hostile to each other. If one party started being an asshole (intolerance) to one or more parties, the peace treaty ends and no one is obliged to be friendly to the one person/group of people being a dick anymore.
If the objection is that a Mullvad co-owner used his money for a disagreeable purpose, is it not better to take money from Mullvad so it has less?
Or could it be that the actual objection is something other? Something unstated?
These are vocal minorities that most times don’t even act on what they espouse, the rhetoric is their sole objective. 9 in 10 of them who were mullvad customers likely remain mullvad customers, and the others never mattered anyway.
Since I live under a rock, I just found out about this. Has there been any additional writeup/report about what the community discussions mentioned in this statement were? I’m pretty confused and sad about it.
I think some of the confusion in the above comments demonstrates the lack of transparency in this decision. Even if there is disagreement about what the right approach is, I do believe that the public deserves a proper assessment so they can make their own judgement and can learn from it.
Otherwise, the effective function of this PR statement is to massage public opinion into accepting a controversial decision without drawing too much attention. Presumably because Tor Project Inc (TPI) relies on volunteer labour as well as donations, and it doesn’t want to loose reputation with other human rights NGOs.
I think it should be emphasised that Mullvad does not donate to TPI in the same way individuals donate, or even the “mega” donors or grants. Instead they are essentially paying for a product (Mullvad Browser) to be made by TPI employees. This product acts as an advert for their paid-for VPN service because it is branded the same and it is bundled with their VPN addon. And it is unclear if the ethnonationalist-funding co-CEO/co-owner of Mullvad expects to make a return on investment on the money given to TPI, or whether it is a vanity project.
The decision to maintain the relationship was made by TPI upper management. As an employee developer at the time, I would have wanted to either end the relationship or negotiate a change so that Mullvad Browser would become de-branded (new name, functions the same, but not promoting the company or its VPN). Unlike the public, I saw an overview of why the decision to continue as is was made. But I was not privy to the details of the assessments that were made, and they did not think to share their own complete scenario analysis with the workers below them, let alone the public. And I don’t even know what they did or didn’t consider, or what the discussions with Mullvad were like.
I would say to anyone who expected more from Tor Project as a company to look elsewhere for your ethics. Tor and Tor Browser can be useful tools, and the developers and other people at the bottom of the org are overall decent, but understand the limitations of an NGO that currently internally mirrors a corporate structure, that depends significantly on the money of a few wealthy “tech bros” (e.g. see https://web.archive.org/web/20260930000513/https://www.torproject.org/about/supporters/).